Filmed: June 19-21, 2013 | Aired: December 4, 2013
- Redemption Island duel: "House of Cards" - Laura M. wins easily, Tina sits in second place.
- Redemption Island eliminated person: Caleb, whose stack collapses as the arbitrary 30-minute time limit elapses.
- Idol hands: Using the clue Laura M. gave to Ciera, Tyson finds the idol again, mere hours after playing it.
- Immunity challenge: "Ram-Ball On" - Gervase wins! Barely, over Monica.
- Voted out: Hayden and Monica deadlock in a 3-3 tie, forcing Katie, Ciera, and Tyson to draw rocks. Katie (picking first) draws the fateful white rock, and is sent to Redemption Island.
Episode 12 scoring notes
- Oh, the no-longer-purple rock. When this happened to Paschal in Marquesas, we threw up our hands at trying to figure out a way to adjust Paschal's score to reflect his leaving the game without having any votes cast against him. Since then, we haven't had any major brainstorms, so we'll score Katie's the same way: not doing anything out of the ordinary. Everyone gets punished for this, because everyone attended Tribal Council, but nobody voted for the person who was booted. Just that Katie gets punished slightly more, by being sent to Redemption Island. But it balances out, since her score is artificially inflated, due to not being "voted" out.
Vote count:
- Monica received 3 votes, from Ciera, Hayden, and Katie.
- Hayden received 3 votes, from Tyson, Monica, and Gervase.
- (Rock draw: Tyson, Ciera, and Katie pick rocks, with Gervase immune and Hayden/Monica ineligible due to the deadlocked tie. Katie out, after drawing the white rock.)