Filmed: March 29-31, 2012 | Aired: October 17, 2012
- Idol time: Scrambling Malcolm and Denise find Matsing's idol before leaving Matsing; Malcolm keeps it.
- Reward challenge: "Idol Hands" - The newly refurbished Tandang (mit Malcolm!) knocks Kalabaw down a peg (or an idol) or two, gaining breakfast items and a highly caffeinated new tribemate.
- Medevac: Dana is removed with a fever/quits, Day 12.
- Immunity challenge: "Thrash, Splash and Bash" - Thanks to a slow-footed Katie and Dawson/Penner puzzle bickering, Tandang wins again.
- Voted out: Dawson, 5-1 over Denise. Ending the Jeff Kent! potential outing drama. Boo.
Episode 5 scoring notes
- Hooray! The end of the three-tribe wonkiness! Also: two challenges!
- *Dana's removal: Oh no! We have to do our artificial vote-out for someone who had to (chose to) leave for medical reasons! Once again: The formula for that is to pretend that Dana was unanimously voted out by all 7 members of her tribe. We gave her a pretend tribal council appearance as well, just so that things weren't divided by zero. But in reality, Dana left without ever attending tribal. Her actual totals appear in the full Season 25 scores.
Vote count:
- Dawson received 5 votes, from Denise, Penner, Jeff Kent!, Carter, and Katie (voted out, 5-1).
- Denise received 1 vote, from Dawson.