Filmed: November 9-11, 2007 | Aired: March 6, 2008
                    
                      
                      
                       
                      
                        - Swap: Ozzy and Natalie draw the colored rocks, get to be captains in the schoolyard pick for new teams, which forces everyone to pick someone from the opposite original tribe. Eliza and Chet are the last picked (by default).
- Reward challenge: "Cat and Mouse" - It's the one where Joel drags Chet around like a rag doll, losing two of the three points Malakal gives up. Also four people are injured, including Penner, who makes it through the episode, but not much beyond that. Airai wins barbecue, and the ocean washes away their fire, which they built in the tidal zone as an homage to Rupert, or something.
- Immunity challenge: "A Stone's Throw" - Joel can't break a tile, Chet can't direct a puzzle. Both are at fault, one will go.
- Voted out: Joel, 6-2, over Chet. Cirie isn't having any of that "weak" nonsense.
 
                   
                  
                    Episode 5 scoring notes
                    
                      
                        - Pretty standard scoring, albeit on new teams.
 
                   
                  
                    Vote count: 
                    
                      
                        - Joelreceived 6 votes, from Amanda, Ami, Chet, Cirie, Ozzy, and Tracy (voted out, 6-2).
- Chet received 2 votes, from Erik and Joel.